Marital conflict: assigning blame
So many couples find themselves immersed in the blame/shame game. [...]
Why Do We Keep Having the Same Fight?
By Larry Pemberton, Ph.D., LPC-MHSP
It starts with something small. A text that went unanswered. A late arrival. Dishes left in the sink. Within minutes, the two of you are in a familiar place: one voice getting louder, the other going quiet, and both of you walking away hurt.
A week later, a different topic leads to the very same argument.
If that sounds like your marriage, you are not alone, and you are not doing it wrong. In more than forty years of working with couples, I have heard this from more partners than I can count: “We keep having the same fight, and we don’t even know what it’s about anymore.”
Here is the good news. It usually isn’t about the dishes. And once you see what it is about, the fight starts to lose its grip.
The Pattern Behind the Fight
In Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT), we call this repeating pattern the cycle. The most common version is called pursue-withdraw.
Consider Sarah and Sam, a composite couple drawn from many I’ve worked with. When Sarah feels distant from Sam, she pursues. She asks questions, raises her voice, points out what’s wrong. She is trying to get a response, any response.
Sam feels that pressure and withdraws. He goes quiet, changes the subject, or leaves the room. He is trying to calm things down before they get worse.
The trouble is that each move sets off the other. The more Sarah pushes, the more Sam pulls away. The more Sam pulls away, the harder Sarah pushes. Round and round they go, each one convinced the other is the problem.
Some couples have two pursuers who escalate into loud battles. Others have two withdrawers who drift into a quiet, lonely distance. The shape varies, but the loop is the same.
What’s Really Going On Underneath
What we see on the surface, the criticism and the shutting down, is only the tip of the iceberg. Underneath are softer feelings that rarely get said out loud.
When Sarah pursues, what she often feels inside is something like “I’m afraid I’m losing you. Do I still matter to you?”
When Sam withdraws, he often feels “I’m afraid I’m failing you. Nothing I do is ever enough.”
Both of them are asking the same deep question: “Will you be there for me when I need you?” They are just asking it in ways that push the other person away.
That’s why I tell couples that the cycle is the enemy, not your partner. Your spouse isn’t the bad guy. You’re both caught in a pattern that is hurting you both. When couples begin to see this, something shifts. The question changes from “Who’s to blame?” to “How do we beat this together?”
Three Things to Try This Week
These steps won’t fix everything, but they can help you catch the cycle earlier and begin to turn toward each other.
When You Can’t Break It on Your Own
Most couples I see have tried hard to stop fighting. The problem isn’t effort. It’s that the cycle moves fast, and in the heat of the moment, it is very hard to see it from the inside.
That’s where couples therapy can help. In EFT, we slow the fight down together. We map out your particular cycle, help each of you understand the fears and needs underneath, and practice new ways of reaching for each other. Over time, couples learn to step out of the pattern and build a bond that feels safe again. Research on EFT has shown strong results for helping couples reduce conflict and rebuild closeness.
You don’t have to wait for things to get worse to reach out. If you keep finding yourselves in the same fight, that is a good reason to call.
Ready to take the next step? The therapists at Healing Hearts Counseling in Knoxville specialize in Emotionally Focused couples therapy. Contact us to schedule a session.
Larry Pemberton, Ph.D., LPC-MHSP, is a Certified Emotionally Focused Couples Therapist at Healing Hearts Counseling. He has been married for 54 years.